Acrylic liner vs tiled shower
Updated November 2026
Choose an acrylic liner or prefab system if you want the lowest price and the fastest install, and the standard sizes and looks suit you. Choose a tiled shower if you want it waterproofed behind the walls, any size or style, and the finish most people picture in a renovated bathroom. We build tiled showers, so we have a side in this, but here is the comparison as fairly as we can make it.
Acrylic systems are sold by national brands such as Bath Fitter and by local installers: moulded acrylic walls and a base, fitted over or in place of the old tub and surround. A tiled shower is built from the studs: a sloped base, a waterproof membrane, then tile and glass.
Side by side
| Acrylic liner / prefab | Tiled shower | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical cost (Metro Vancouver) | $3,500 – $10,000 | $11,900 – $18,000 (curbless from $15,900) |
| Install time | Often 1–2 days | 1–2 weeks |
| What happens to the old walls | Often covered, depending on the installer | Removed to the studs; rot or old pipe is found and fixed |
| Waterproofing | The acrylic surface and its seams | A continuous membrane behind every tile and under the base |
| Sizes and layouts | Fixed sizes and shapes | Any size, niches, benches, curbless |
| Looks | A set range of colours and patterns | Any tile, any pattern |
| Cleaning | Smooth, few joints, easy to wipe | Grout lines need occasional cleaning and sealing |
| Changing it later | Replace the whole unit | Repair a tile or re-grout |
When an acrylic liner makes sense
- A rental or a home you are selling soon, where speed and cost matter most.
- The walls behind the tub are known to be sound and dry.
- A standard tub-sized alcove and a style from the catalogue you like.
When a tiled shower is worth it
- You are staying, and the bathroom should last and look custom.
- The old surround has leaked, or the house is older and you want to see what is behind the walls.
- You want a curbless or step-free entry, a bench, a niche or a size that isn’t standard.
Questions to ask any installer
- Are the old walls removed, or covered?
- What is the waterproofing behind the finished surface?
- What exactly does the warranty cover, and for how long?
- Is the price for the shower only, or does it include the vanity, toilet and floor?
Bath Fitter is a trademark of its owner; this guide describes acrylic systems in general and isn’t affiliated with any brand.